My old tabby never cared for catnip either, even when he was young. These days he likes a soft toy he can carry around, and a treat puzzle that makes him think a little before he eats. I keep the play sessions short and gentle now, because he tires quickly, but he still gets excited when he hears the puzzle rattle. I would not worry about the catnip — plenty of cats are the same.
One of my two indoor cats loves catnip and the other completely ignores it, so I have to buy toys in pairs. The one who ignores it is obsessed with a feather wand and a small crinkle ball, and she will play with those for ages. I work from home, so I keep a few different toys in a drawer and swap them out during the day — that seems to keep them interesting for longer.
My long-haired cat also ignores catnip completely, so I stopped buying catnip toys. What he loves is a feather wand — I can drag it slowly across the floor and he stalks it like prey — and brush time, which he treats as a reward. A crinkle ball works too, because the sound gets his attention even without any scent.