In my experience, Persians are also incredibly popular here. My aunt has two, and every time I visit, I see why people love them so much. Their calm personalities and that signature fluffy coat make them a favorite, especially for people who like a more laid-back cat.
Siamese cats are really popular in the U.S. too. I had one growing up, and she was talkative, playful, and followed me everywhere like a shadow. Whenever I go to cat cafés or pet expos, I notice Siamese cats always get a lot of attention from visitors.
From what I’ve seen, Ragdolls are quickly becoming one of the top breeds in America. My friend adopted one last year, and it’s the most affectionate cat I’ve ever met. It flops in your arms like a baby—no wonder they’re so popular with families.
My tabby is a rescue, so he is officially a domestic shorthair, which is really the most common cat in the country if you count the shelter cats. He has the classic tabby markings and the easygoing American Shorthair temperament that Bufordunild mentioned. I think that is worth remembering in a list like this — the most popular cat most people actually live with is the one they adopted from a shelter.
I live in an apartment, so breed temperament matters a lot to me. My two indoor cats are both rescues, but if I were choosing a breed, I would look at the Ragdoll and the British Shorthair first — both are calm, happy indoors, and good with a quieter home. The Maine Coon is lovely, but I think my apartment would be too small for a cat that big.