I have two cats and one of them is a total food thief — he finishes his own bowl in seconds and then pushes his sister away from hers. I work long shifts so I can't always supervise mealtimes, and she's starting to lose weight while he's getting chunky. I've heard about microchip feeders and feeders with separate compartments but I don't know what actually works in a real house. Has anyone solved this without feeding them in separate rooms every single time?
A microchip feeder was the thing that finally worked for us. Our greedy one figured out a timed feeder in about a day, but the microchip one only opens for the right cat, so his sister can graze in peace. They're pricey, but cheaper than the vet bills from one cat gaining weight and the other losing it.
Separate rooms worked for us in the short term, but the real fix was feeding on a schedule instead of leaving food down all day. We started putting the slower cat's bowl up on a shelf her brother can't jump to — she's lighter and more agile, so it worked. A microchip feeder is on our list too, but honestly the raised spot plus set mealtimes solved most of it for free.
We had the same food thief problem and a microchip feeder was the only thing that really worked — the timed feeders just got raided the moment they opened. If a microchip feeder is too much right now, try feeding the slower cat on a high surface the other one can't reach. It worked for us as a stopgap for a few months.
We tried the separate compartments feeder first and it worked for about a week until the greedy one learned to push the lid open. The microchip feeder was the real answer for us. It felt expensive at the time, but our girl has put her weight back on and he's stopped stealing, so it was worth every penny.